Colin's blog
The City So Nice They Named It Twice
A Comprehensive Guide To The Five Boroughs Of The Metropolis
These guidebooks were the start of the proliferation of information about travel destinations that is so accessible to us today. The guide employs a strategic and effective mix of useful factual information, poetic prose romanticizing the city, great illustrations of the city, and beautiful black and white photography of various neighborhoods and landmarks. It notes in the preface, “This volume is a detailed description of the communities and points of interest in all the five boroughs of New York City. It attempts, also, to indicate the human character of the city, to point out the evidence of achievements and shortcomings, urban glamor as well as urban sordidness”. The book also features quotes by famous people to entice prospective tourists, such as this one by Henry Hudson: “It is as beautiful a land as one can hope to tread on”. The guide highlights some of the points of interest such as the New York Public Library, Coney Island, Central Park, the World’s Fair grounds, and Wall Street. Equally, it notes the human character of the city, including the high society types like the Astors, Woolworths, Phipps’, and Rockefellers, as well as the ethnic neighborhoods of Harlem, Chinatown, and Brooklyn.
A perfect illustration of how the guide seeks to mix factual information with a depiction of the urban glamor and urban sordidness of New York, can be found in a passage that reads, “In the city, night workers, their footsteps sharp, irregular on the quiet streets, return home. A water wagon rolls by. Bands are still playing in half a dozen night clubs. In the Upper East Side, in the Upper West Side, in the Gashouse and Hell’s Kitchen, in Chelsea and Greenwich Village, the faint and broken ringing of the alarm clocks come to the empty street. Another day, another dollar. Don’t forget to tell the laundryman not to starch my shirts! Slowly the air between the buildings fills with light…The boy who came to be a writer is waked in his mid-town room and dresses for his shift on the elevator. In Chelsea the girl who came to be an actress launders her stockings. The boy who was going to Wall Street sprawls on his bed, wincing as each cry cuts into his dream of the smell of fresh hay and warm milk…Night draws to a close. Bands are still playing behind closed doors of a half dozen night clubs.”(P.51) The guide book seems to present the same romanticized stereotype of New York that is prominent today. A restless mixing pot of various cultures, with endless attractions to see. A place where everybody has big dreams, and opportunities and vice are abundant. Although there is no challenge in acquiring any sort of information on any given city these days, at least certain romanticized versions of cities still exist in our culture.
Hot Dogs and Roadside Camps
The Advent of the American Leisure Class
Agee does seem to be concerned with the flourishing economy that rose up from the American roadside, but he is writing about the boom period of the 1920s, before the Great Depression. He romanticizes the experience of being on the road, immersing oneself in the various pockets of American cultures in different areas of the country. Reminiscent of a 1920s Anthony Bourdain, he writes about the challenge of getting a proper barbeque sandwich, and the importance of the hot dog as an American symbol. Agee writes about the advent and economics of the American roadside camp as if he is the authority on the subject. To him, the American roadside camp is the ultimate symbol for the growing American leisure class. He writes, “For the tourist camp is one sound invention that the American roadside has contributed to the American scene. And as an invention it is more satisfying than the hot dog.”(Agee P.52) Both the hot dog and the tourist camp serve as perfect American symbols, because they are both accessible and universal across various classes, and perfectly pragmatic.
Berkowitz describes many of the vital factors that led to the institutionalization of the travel habit as an American past time. He acknowledges the movement for paid vacations and the promotion of travel by the railroad and hospitality industries that began in the mid 1800s and grew until the turn of the century as essential to the creation of the leisure class. However, he credits the Great Depression as a perfect storm of interests in American travel as the turning point, writing, “The crisis of the depression was ultimately responsible for completing the transformation of tourism into a mass phenomenon. As the 1930s progressed, management’s desire to secure industrial peace and labor’s increasing militancy and consumerist ideology brought about a frenzied expansion of paid vacations to a majority of wage earners. At the same time, the New Deal-era interest in promoting social harmony and in encouraging new consumption practices to revitalize the economy compelled business leaders and government officials on both the local and the national levels to intensify their tourism promotional activities and spread vacationing beyond its formerly middle and upper-class base.”(Berkowitz P. 187)
The desire for both industry and government to stimulate spending during the Great Depression reminds me of 9/11 when President Bush asked the country to be patriotic by going to the mall and spending, spending, spending. We can credit the period that Berkowitz described as the origin of our consumer culture today. We have gotten to the point that when our massive consumer culture, now fueled mostly by credit and debt, slows down just a little bit it can cause a national economic crisis itself.
Vaudevillian Literature
Nathaniel West's Story of the American Nightmare
How To Make It In (Depression-Era) America
Riding Freight Trains To Nowhere With Charles Willeford
After losing his mother to T.B. he moved in with his grandmother. However, after the stock market crash in 1929, his grandmother was housing additional extended family, and the young Willeford felt himself becoming a burden to the household. Although the economic circumstance of the family, and the country at large, caused the young willeford, just barely a teenager, to venture outward-bound, the reader gets the feeling that he also yearned for a certain sense of adventure that we heard about in the documentary about hobos we watched in class on Tuesday. He writes, “I left home and went on the road. I wasn’t alone. For the next few years there were thousands of boys my age riding freight trains to nowhere. But no one can ever tell me I didn’t have a happy childhood.”(P. 45)
Having largely been raised middle class the young Willeford had to learn the ways of the hobo quicly in order to adapt to his surroundings. He learned a lot of vital advice on the road such as when he explains, “When I first hit the road, a bum in Colton, California, had told me that a man should always have a destination of some kind in his mind, even though he had no real plan and knew in his heart that he was going nowhere.”(P. 59) Little tricks like this helped Willeford learn how to trick himself into believing he had an inckling of direction and purpose, and fooling the authorities, so as not to be arrested. He went beyond simply creating a false destination though, making an entire fictitious back story including a new name for himself, Jake Lowey, which he got from his one-eyed uncle. Willeford’s first hand account of what it was like to grow up on the railroads of the South Western United States is very interesting, and fits perfectly into the body of work that we have been reading and discussing. Ultimately, the reader sees that growing up on the road is not so much different from growing up anywhere else. Willeford, or Jake Lowey, makes a few friends who realize that their odds of survival are much better in a group, and learns how to navigate the social circles of the work camps. He seems to encourage the reader to embark on their own journey, writing brief sentiments such as, “As long as a man leaves everything behind, including his money posessions, and clothes, he will have no regrets when he begins a life somewhere else. “(P. 18)
Although, growing up homeless, and alone on the road during the Great Depression would have been a horrowing experience, Willeford seems to embrace the adventure, and exude a sense of pride for accomplishing the feet. His optimism radiates in passages such as this one: “If I could learn how to drive a car I could go to Miami Beach, maybe, and drive a taxicab. Or I could go to San Francisco, or Seattle, or Alaska. Why not Alaska, that is, If I could get a good used Navy pea jacket first. My possibilities were limitless. One man alone, without responsibilties, has got a fighting chance in this world; and it was, indeed, a wonderful world.” (P. 146) All in all, It is a great story, and I highly recommend reading the book.
Just Getting By
Tom Kromer's Depiction of Survival During The Great Depression
The opening Chapter illustrates a man pushed to the margins of his own notions of right and wrong, struggling with his own middle class morals, in the face of the extreme necessity to survive. The stiff contemplates and plans to mug a stranger on the street with a stick to rob him for money to eat. Ultimately, he is unable to abandon his morals to go through with the attack, and is ashamed that he was considering doing so, and that he did not have the courage to do what it takes to survive, until the stranger angrily insults him for asking for money to get something to eat. It is clear that such sacrifices of his morality have taken a toll on his sense of identity when he writes, “I am starved, too, and I ought to starve. A guy without enough guts to get himself a feed ought to starve.”(P. 6) As many Americans were forced out of their homes it seems that they shed a part of their identity when they left their environment, such as when Momma Joad burns her families treasured documents in The Grapes of Wrath. His stark description of himself staring at the well to do nibbling at expensive chickens while he nearly starves to death on the other side of the window is one of the most graphic images illustrating the failure of capitalism, presented in the pieces we have read.
I Ain't Got No Home In This World Anymore
Woody Guthrie's account of his travels westward
Although he faces the same dire circumstances, including starvation, as the thousands of other migrants workers, he presents his story in an uplifting way, which reminds me of Huckleberry Finn. Unable to continue living in the shrinking Texas town of Pampa, plagued with the Dust Bowl, Woody begins his travels. Before hitting the road he briefly reminisces about the town he is leaving behind him, saying, “Good ol Pampa. I hit here in 1926. Worked my tail off ‘round this here town. But it didn’t give me anything. Town had growed up, strung itself all out across these plains. Just a little old low-built cattle town to start with; jumped up big when the oil boom hit. Now eleven years later it had up and died.”(P. 191) This journey undoubtedly went on to become an important inspiration for his lyrics that would go on to become the unofficial anthem of Okies and migrants throughout the nation. It becomes clear from reading his autobiographic story, why so many migrants were able to identify with his music. He exemplifies how many places he had been, and how many people he had met, when he writes, “I had seen thousands of men that looked the same way, and could usually tell by the color of the dirt[ on their faces], where they were from”. (P. 195) It goes to show how well he understood his surroundings, including the people and the settings of the mass migration during the Great Depression.
Guthrie displays his easy-going mentality that he adopts towards his unfortunate situation when he writes, “Where was I going? I was going to California. What for? Oh, just to see if I couldn’t do a little better.(P. 194) His acceptance of the circumstance he is dealt, and his embracement of the migrant lifestyle serves to inform much of his music. His recollection an anecdote from the road-“We were four guys out, trying to get somewhere in the world, and the roar of that little engine, rattly, knocky, and funny as it was, had a good sound to our ears. It was the only motor we had. We wanted more than anything else in the world to hear it purr along, and we didn’t care how people laughed as they went around us, and throwed their clouds of red dust back into our faces”. (P. 196)-could easily have been the inspiration for the song, Riding In My Car. It seems that Guthrie truly enjoyed being on the road and living for the brief moments of triumph, and pleasure, rather than concern himself with the grim future that lay ahead out west.
- Login to post comments
"Livin’ a Bum’s Life Soon Makes a Bum Out of You "
The Various Migrations of the Great Depression in Photos and Text
The photographs that are presented in An American Exodus provide a visceral element to the narratives that we have been reading about already, and to ones that we have not covered such as those in the American south. She describes the nature and effect of their collaboration, stating, “We use the camera as a tool of research. Upon a tripod of photographs, captions, and text we rest themes evolved out of long observations in the field. We adhere to the standards of documentary photography as we have conceived them”. (P. 15) Her recognition of their adherence to standards of documentary photography “as we have conceived them” makes the reader/viewer wonder how many creative liberties she took in staging her photographs in order to convey her desired effect. However, despite the debate over the integrity of the work of the photographers working for the Information Division of the Farm Security Administration (Source), the combination of photographs and quotations of the subjects provide the viewer/reader with a unique window into a period of American history, and more specifically into the lives of a marginalized group of migrants, living on the fringes of society.
I was particularly interested in the narratives described by the photos and text that chronicled the migrant farmers from the south, particularly the African Americans that had been freed from slavery, but still struggled to find a way to make a living by farming the land. The most disappointing fact brought to light by the piece concerning the migrant farmers in the south, was that as a result of the eroded plantation system that once kept them enslaved, the land was now ruined. Arthur F. Raper is quoted in An American Exodus in 1937, saying, “The collapse of the plantation system, rendered inevitable by its exploitation of land and labor, leaves in its wake depleted soil, shoddy livestock, inadequate farm equipment, crude agricultural practices, crippled institutions, a defeated and impoverished people”. This helps to explain the mass exodus of southern African American migrant farm workers relocating to urban cities in the north. A couple, born into slavery, on an abandoned twenty-eight-family plantation was quoted commenting on their disenfranchisement after the abolition of slavery, saying, “I remember when the Yankees come through, a whole, passel of em hollerin, and told the Negroes you’re free. But they didn’t get nothing cause we had carried the best horses and mules over to the gulley”. (Greene County, Georgia/July 1937) Lange’s photo of the couple is an arresting image, but it gets its power largely from the context that the text provides. Another interesting use of text and photography, which illustrates how the two complement each other in An American Exodus, employs a quote by the President’s Committee on Farm Tenancy that states, “The committees examination of the agricultural ladder has indicated an increasing tendency for the rungs of the ladder to become bars-forcing imprisonment in a fixed social status from which it is increasingly difficult to escape”. (P. 24) The quote is accompanied by a photo of a dilapidated staircase, with broken steps, to symbolize the broken rungs of the agricultural system.
The piece also details the influx of migrant farmers in California, forced westward from the Draught Bowl. It confirms the hostile climate that the migrants arrived in California to, described by John Steinbeck in The Grapes of Wrath. It highlights the reaction of the Police Chief of Los Angeles’ reaction to these unemployed migrants, pointing out that “His remedy, reflecting initiative but stretching legal authority, was to overawe and thus impede the human influx by stationing Los Angeles policemen at the ports of land entry to the state, even to its farthest corners.”(P. 130)
- Login to post comments
Traveling Men
Asch and Pyle set out on the road to document depression-era America
Both pieces exude this feeling that the financial crisis has brought about the end of an era, and that the country is changing dramatically, in both its physical landscape and the mentality of its citizens. Asch alludes to this paradigm change by describing his experiences in Detroit. His travels there allow him to experience first hand the fall of the automobile industry, which helped at one time to define American prosperity. Pyle describes the change in the dynamics of a community in a Montana cattle town prior to the Depression, stating, “You could leave a gold watch, and fifty dollars, and a jug of whiskey, and a sack of tobacco on the table. When you came home the whiskey and the tobacco might be gone, but the fifty dollars and the gold watch would always be there.”(Pyle 54) Moreover, the reader gets the feeling from the two pieces that the citizens of the areas affected by the depression generally feel tense, and hostile towards one another. Asch points out the hostility that exists between the co-workers in the auto plants, towards their superiors, the suspicion of the executives towards a reporter, and the hostility that the police treated him with, simply for being a stranger in town, stopping him on the street and telling him, “There ain’t no charge. But Hamtramck is no place for tourists and we don’t see no reason for you to be hanging around.”(Asche 263)
Both pieces end with a Hollywood ending, describing the pleasures of traveling for a living, and seeing the vast country. Both authors leave the reader with a reminder that although the Great Depression affected a large portion of the country, there were still many Americans still living well, and some traveling not out of necessity, but for pleasure. Pyle describes the advantages of traveling during this time, in his response to the question of whether or not he was tired of traveling after a long time. He replied, “The answer is an honest no, though it isn’t impossible that some of these days we might come to hate the impermanency of travel. I’ve tried to figure out myself why we haven’t tired of it. And my conclusion is that our travel is ameans of excape. We don’t have to stay and face anything out if we don’t like a place, we can move on. If something happens that isn’t pleasant we can leave and settle it later by letter, or just let it go forever. Stability cloaks you with a thousand little personal responsibilities, and we have been able to flee from them."(Pyle 468)
- Login to post comments
The Philosophy of Grapes
Frederick Carpenter on Steinbeck
The Grapes of Wrath, like the other classic novels mentioned above, preserved in text, a time in American history, and was able to both capture, and influence, the sentiment of the nation. As a result, it has become a timeless work of art that serves as an integral piece of American culture. Carpenter goes on to assert that, The Grapes of Wrath serves to “Preach a positive philosophy of life and to damn that blind conservatism which fears ideas”. After reading the novel for the first time, I agree that despite the many bleak situations, and sentiments, depicted in the novel, that Steinbeck ultimately is communicating an optimistic and hopeful message about the human condition, despite his criticism of the failures of capitalism in America. I believe that statement also explains the discourse about Steinbeck’s intention to promote communism within the novel. Rather than attempting to advance any agenda, Steinbeck is attempting to explore different ideas uninhibitedly, and denounce a conservative approach to discredit ideas without exploring their merit. Jim Casey provides the possibility for these ideas to be discussed and explored in the narrative. Moreover, because Casey is no longer a preacher in the story, it allows for a discourse between him and the other characters, where they are able to challenge the ideas presented by the Casey, which they would not be able to do if he was still a Preacher.
While Carpenter notes the importance of the interpretive inter-chapters that Steinbeck employs to communicate abstract ideas in the novel, he focuses on the character of the preacher Jim Casey as Steinbeck’s primary tool to “interpret and to embody the philosophy of the novel.” In addition, he alludes to Steinbeck’s use of Jim Casey as a vehicle to communicate and transform the philosophies of other acclaimed American writers through the character, and influence the narrative and the reader. Carpenter explains the effectiveness of this method, as an essential factor in the novel’s success, saying, “The ideas of John Steinbeck and Jim Casey…continue, develop, integrate, and realize the thought of the great writers of American history. Here the mystical transcendentalism of Emerson appears, and the earthy democracy of Whitman, and the pragmatic instrumentalism of William James and John Dewey. And these old philosophies grow and change in the book until they become new. They coalesce into an organic whole. And, finally, they find embodiment in the character and action, so that they seem no longer ideas, but facts. The enduring greatness of The Grapes of Wrath consists in its imaginative realization of these old ideas in new and concrete forms. Jim Casey translates American philosophy into words of one syllable, and the Joads translate it into action.”
- Login to post comments
Tramps Take to the Road By Choice
On the Road in America with Two Tramps
I would like to share the stories of two tramps that I found noteworthy. I recently read a memoir called “I Was Looking for a Street”, by Charles Willeford, who grew up in Los Angeles during the Great Depression. With both of his parents dead, he lived with his grandmother along with many other kids. Sensing that he was becoming too much of a burden for his grandmother to handle, financially, he took to the railroads and headed out on the road. It’s a fascinating coming of age/travel story, where he describes his discovery of the hobo/tramp culture, learning how to navigate the railroads, Depression-era America, and childhood. His story makes the reader realize that for the many kids traveling by themselves at this time, growing up was something they were forced to do to survive. He stays in the desert, abandoned prisons, work camps, and tent cities. He shares his first experiences getting drunk, losing his virginity, and making his friends on the road.
Another interesting true story of a tramp on the road in America, is that of Chrisopher McCandles, which was popularized by John Krakauer’s book, “Into the Wild”, and Sean Penn’s film of the same name. I saw the movie when it came out in 2007, and found McCandles’ story inspiring. After graduating college from Emerson University, he decided to donate all of his money to charity, and hit the road with nothing but the clothes on his back and minimal supplies. Although his story takes place long after the Great Depression, it is clear that he was inspired by the romanticized vision of traveling the country with nothing but a deep curiosity driving him to explore. I would highly recommend both “I Was Looking For a Street” and “Into the Wild”. They are both great travel stories that exhibit people who had the courage to leave home without a destination, aside from the road itself.
The "Main Street" of America
Traveling Along America's first and favorite highway, Route 66
- Login to post comments
A Traveller Who Had Been to New York-But Not America
An Englishman's Take On Depression-Era America
He certainly spends a great deal of time writing about the cult popularity of trailers and the diverse uses that they serve in American culture. From serving as sites where children were born on Route 101, to “love-nests”, to murder scenes, to dressing rooms for Hollywood stars. He makes the reader believe that the trailer, an American icon, can serve as a microcosm for American culture. From low-brow to high-brow, and from functional to superfluous, the trailer is a ubiquitous part of American culture. In the 1930’s, the trailer served as homes to American families who needed to have a family home on wheels, to be able to scour the country for work, as well as luxury dressing rooms for movie stars to pass time in. The trailer transcends the glitzy stereotypes of American life that were presented over-seas, and the gritty truth of American life “from the ground up” in the 1930s.












.jpg)












