Suckerfish

  • A Sense of Place
  • Art of Travel
  • Travel Narratives
  • Archive
    • Course archive
    • Blogroll A-Z
    • Blogroll by course
  • Research
    • Place
    • Travel
    • Search Bobst
    • Citing sources
  • Blogs
    • Log in/Create account
    • Help
    • Home

Blogroll

  • Art of Travel
  • Place
  • Narratives
Alexander's picture
Alexander
ClaireMarie's picture
ClaireMarie
CTS's picture
CTS
Danasaur's picture
Danasaur
Dani's picture
Dani
dmiller's picture
dmiller
francesca's picture
francesca
gecuishan's picture
gecuishan
Godot's picture
Godot
Helen's picture
Helen
Idabelle's picture
Idabelle
Jackie's picture
Jackie
jacques's picture
jacques
jacquieh's picture
jacquieh
jlhaurenh's picture
jlhaurenh
jocelyn's picture
jocelyn
lafish's picture
lafish
lillian's picture
lillian
Monica's picture
Monica
naomi's picture
naomi
Natasha's picture
Natasha
nm123's picture
nm123
ouiyasmin's picture
ouiyasmin
alizaba's picture
alizaba
asif's picture
asif
Batman's picture
Batman
BigEcho's picture
BigEcho
Biz's picture
Biz
Clare's picture
Clare
Daniel's picture
Daniel
eastcoast's picture
eastcoast
frances's picture
frances
Ism2021's picture
Ism2021
JohnRussell's picture
JohnRussell
leila's picture
leila
Mechanical's picture
Mechanical
Mina's picture
Mina
msquared's picture
msquared
Phi's picture
Phi
sesamebun's picture
sesamebun
Tae's picture
Tae
Taylor's picture
Taylor
Tonya's picture
Tonya
Woles's picture
Woles
AAZ's picture
AAZ
ahavanur's picture
ahavanur
camcam's picture
camcam
Caro's picture
Caro
CM's picture
CM
ddanielle's picture
ddanielle
DKF's picture
DKF
HQ's picture
HQ
jb's picture
jb
JJordan's picture
JJordan
Jodi's picture
Jodi
Megan's picture
Megan
mmmiz33's picture
mmmiz33
Nick's picture
Nick
Oblivia's picture
Oblivia
Remmy's picture
Remmy
risoSole's picture
risoSole
SAM's picture
SAM
Sarah's picture
Sarah
Taylor's picture
Taylor

Blogs Spring 2013

  • Travel Studies Blogs
    • All posts
    • Post gallery
  • Art of Travel Topics
    • 1. Introductions
    • 2. Arrival
    • 3. Wayfinding
    • 4. Communicating
    • 5. Quotidian life
    • 6. Books (1)
    • 7. Authenticity
    • 8. Art
    • 9. Great good places
    • 10. Books (2)
    • 11. Genius loci
    • 12. The comfort of strangers
    • 13. Epiphanies
    • 14. Tips
    • 15. Final thoughts
  • Sense of Place Topics
    • 1. Experiencing place
    • 2. House
    • 3. Placelessness
    • 4. Landscape
    • 5. Suburbs
    • 6. City Form & Plazas
    • 7. Modernism
    • 8. Utopian visions
    • 9. Contested spaces
    • 10. Urban futures
    • 11. Walking around
    • 12. NYU-landia
    • 13. Seeing New York
  • Travel Narratives Topics
    • 1. Grand Tour
    • 2. Lust to go
    • 3. Going Native
    • 4. Walkabout
    • 5. Maiden Voyages
    • 6. Imperial Eyes
    • 7. Beginner's Mind

Blog Archive

  • Blogroll (A-Z)
  • Blogroll (by course)
  • Courses
    • American Road Trip (Fall 2012)
      • 1. Beginnings
      • 2. Twain
      • 3. Road movies
      • 4. Kerouac-a
      • 5. Kerouac-b
      • 6. Beauvoir
      • 7. Wolfe-a
      • 8. Wolfe-b
      • 9. Steinbeck-a
      • 10. Steinbeck-b
      • 11. Least Heat Moon
      • 12. Final thoughts
      • American Road Trip Comments (Fall 2012)
    • Art of Travel (Fall 2012)
      • 1. Introductions
      • 2. Arrival
      • 3. Wayfinding
      • 4. Communicating
      • 5. Quotidian life
      • 6. Books (1)
      • 7. Authenticity
      • 8. Art
      • 9. Great good places
      • 10. Books (2)
      • 11. Genius loci
      • 12. The comfort of strangers
      • 13. Epiphanies
      • 14. Tips
      • 15. Farewells
      • Art of Travel Comments (Fall 2012)
    • Art of Travel (Spring 2012)
      • 1: Introductions
      • 2. Going places
      • 3. Wayfinding
      • 4. Communicating
      • 5. Quotidian life
      • 6. Books (1)
      • 7. Authenticity
      • 8. The "art" of travel
      • 9. Great good places
      • 10. Books (2)
      • 11. Genius loci
      • 12. The comfort of strangers
      • 13. Epiphanies
      • 14. Tips
      • 15. Farewells
    • Art of Travel (Fall 2011)
      • 1. Introductions
      • 2. Going places
      • 3. Wayfinding
      • 4. Communicating
      • 5. Quotidian life
      • 6. Books (1)
      • 7. Authenticity
      • 8. The "art" of travel
      • 9. Great good places
      • 10. Books (2)
      • 11. Genius loci
      • 12. The comfort of strangers
      • 13. Epiphanies
      • 14. Tips
      • 15. Farewells
    • Art of Travel (Spring 2011)
      • 1. Introductions
      • 2. Going places
      • 3. Wayfinding
      • 4. Communicating
      • 5. Quotidian life
      • 6. Books (1)
      • 7. Authenticity
      • 8. The "art" of travel
      • 9. Great good places
      • 10. Books (2)
      • 11. Genius loci
      • 12. The comfort of strangers
      • 13. Epiphanies
      • 14. Tips
      • 15. Farewells
    • Art of Travel (Spring 2010)
      • 1. Introductions
      • 2. Departure-Arrival Story
      • 3. Traveling places
      • 4. Open Topic
      • 5. Discuss a reading (1)
      • 6. Quotidian life
      • 7. The "art" of travel
      • 8. Open Topic
      • 9. Authenticity
      • 10. Open Topic
      • 11. Discuss a reading (2)
      • 12. Open topic
      • 13. Place
      • 14. Person
      • 15. On habit
      • 16. Thanksgiving story
      • 17. Advice
      • 18. Final Thoughts
    • A Sense of Place (Spring 2011)
      • 1. A good place
      • 2. Tuan
      • 3. Tuan (cont.)
      • 4. Jackson
      • 5. Kunstler
      • 6. Kunstler (cont.)
      • 7. Midterm
      • 8. Waldie
      • 9. Pollan
      • 10. Pollan (cont.)
      • 11. Flint
      • 12. Sorkin
      • 13. Sorkin (cont.)
      • 14. Final
      • 15. Parting Thoughts
    • Travel Classics (Fall 2012)
      • 1. Odyssey
      • 2. Herodotus-a
      • 3. Herodotus-b
      • 4. Marco Polo-a
      • 5. Marco Polo-b
      • 6. Columbus-a
      • 7. Columbus-b
      • 8. Cabeza de Vaca-a
      • 9. Cabeza de Vaca-b
      • 10. Tempest-a
      • 11. Tempest-b
      • 12. Final
      • Travel Classics Comments (Fall 2012)
    • Travel Classics (Spring 2011)
      • 1. Odyssey
      • 2. Herodotus (a)
      • 3. Herodotus (b)
      • 4. Marco Polo (a)
      • 5. Marco Polo (b)
      • 6. Ibn Battuta (a)
      • 7. Ibn Battuta (b)
      • 8. Columbus (a)
      • 9. Columbus (b)
      • 10. Cabeza de Vaca (a)
      • 11. Cabeza de Vaca (b)
      • 12. The Tempest
      • 13. Final thoughts
    • Travel Fictions (Fall 2010)
      • 1. Travel Story
      • 2. Daisy Miller
      • 3. The Sun Also Rises
      • 4. The Sheltering Sky
      • 5. Sociology of tourism
      • 6. On the Road
      • 7. Literary geography
      • 8. Midterm
      • 9. Death in Venice
      • 10. The Comfort of Strangers
      • 11. Elephanta Suite
      • 12. A Concise Chinese-English Dictionary
      • 13. Sputnik Sweetheart
      • 14. Final
    • Travel Habit (Fall 2012)
      • 1. Setting off
      • 2. Writers on the Road
      • 3. Writers on the Road, cont.
      • 4. Waiting for Nothing
      • 5. Travel novels
      • 6. Photo-text books
      • 7. Agee-Evans
      • 8. Grapes of Wrath
      • 9. Grapes of Wrath, cont.
      • 10. A Cool Million
      • 11. Tourism
      • 12. WPA guides
      • Travel Habit Comments (Fall 2012)
    • Travel Habit (Fall 2011)
      • 1. Setting off
      • 2. Grapes of Wrath (1)
      • 3. Grapes of Wrath (2)
      • 4. Grapes of Wrath (3)
      • 5. Writers on the Road
      • 6. Words & Images
      • 7. Travel novels
      • 8. Waiting for Nothing
      • 9. Open topic
      • 10. A Cool Million
      • 11. Tourism & the travel habit
      • 12. WPA Guides
    • Travel Habit (Fall 2010)
      • 1. Setting off
      • 2. Grapes of Wrath (1)
      • 3. Grapes of Wrath (2)
      • 4. Grapes of Wrath (3)
      • 5. Writers on the Road
      • 6. Words & Images
      • 7. Travel novels
      • 8. Waiting for Nothing
      • 9. Open topic
      • 10. A Cool Million
      • 11. Tourism & the travel habit
      • 12. WPA Guides
    • Travel Narratives (Spring 2012)
      • 1. Why we travel
      • 2. Twain
      • 3. Flaubert
      • 4. Orwell
      • 5. Bowles
      • 6. Theroux
      • 7. Chatwin
      • 8. Morris/Davidson
      • 9. Mahoney
      • 10. Kincaid
      • 11. Phillips
      • 12. Cortazar-Botton
      • 13. Final reflections

Comments

  • Blog comments
    • Art of Travel Comments
    • Sense of Place Comments
    • Travel Narratives
    • Recent comments

Recent comments

lafish's picture
lafish: Cafés seem to be a universal good place
lafish's picture
lafish: Right back atcha
ouiyasmin's picture
ouiyasmin: Obviously
lafish's picture
lafish: Love & beauty
lafish's picture
lafish: Split thoughts
Mechanical's picture
Mechanical: Whoa... definitely didn't
AAZ's picture
AAZ: Jaded
Taylor's picture
Taylor: Home
Taylor's picture
Taylor: Great Expectations
Taylor's picture
Taylor: Guide Book Sights
  •  
  • 1 of 410
  • ››

Follow Travel Studies on:

Facebook Twitter YouTube

Latent Imperialism in the modern day

Submitted by labellavita on Tue, 11/16/2010 - 02:19
  • Travel Fictions
  • 11. Elephanta Suite
Yes, it still exists: ergo tourism.
I found myself extremely irritated by the second novella, " The Elephant God." Alice as a character proves herself to be an unlikeable individual: pessimistic, disagreeable, anti-social. I found her to be one of those types of people we've discussed, people who view themselves as intellectually and spiritually above Western society and who want to obtain a form of purity and spiritual guidance through their travels. Alice seems to find everything about The United States worthless, and does not  even bother keeping in touch with her family during her trip. She makes superficial, half-hearted opinions about finding her spiritual side in India, and instead of finding her connection with the elephant to be touching and wholesome, I was just further irritated because of her attitude towards Indian people. Alice likes the idea of being able to say that she went to an ashram and was spiritually cleansed,but is constantly putting down Indian people and looking for faults in each different sector of the society that she encounters. Her job as an English instructor just emphasizes the sense of superiority: she is not teaching these people English because she feels a compassionate desire to better the lives of these people and empower them. She wants to feel like they need her for a skill, and is shocked when this turns on her and she corrupts their former authenticity. One thing that especially annoyed me about Alice was when she would speak to the Indians in broken English, almost mocking them. Since she was so insecure about herself in almost every aspect of her life, she tried to create a superiority through her skills with language. I am not sure what I think about Alice's rape, and the way that she kills off Amitabh. She considers herself damaged and injured, but at the same time refuses to let him win. Tables turn and she is the victim: not only in the sense that she was assaulted, but through the chauvinism she encounters after she presses charges. I felt that this just further antagonized India from Alice's point of view. Like the first novella,( however, that one did not bother me quite so much) the Elephant God shows India to be gruesome and wild, unpredictable and playing tricks on the Westerners who think they have conquered it. Just when they think that they have established a rule over the natives of this exotic land, there is always a force lurking in the shadows- whether a looming sense of malaise or the realization that the savvy American is completely and utterly alone. 
  • labellavita's blog
  • Login to post comments
RoopleTheme